Tuesday, May 19, 2009

Get Back To Where You Belong

Yesterday I promised to discuss the new FASB ruling. After 11/15/09 banks will be forced to move their off balance sheet vehicles onto their balance sheets. The result will be that billions of dollars of assets and liabilities will need to recognized for banks. Most of these assets are considered to be securities and, thanks to a recent, notable FASB rule change, banks will not have to mark these assets to market. However, they will need to value these securities in some fashion. The bank vigilantes will want to know the details of these newly on balance sheet structures and will be on the lookout for favorable valuations by banks. These assets were not part of bank stress tests.

Speaking of stress tests, concern is building in the markets for smaller regional and local banks. Many of these banks are exposed to commercial mortgages which have little (if any) chance of paying off in full. Although the so-called "Big 19" banks are too big to fail, their smaller brethren are not. Distressed smaller banks will continue to put a crimp in mortgage lending. The worst of the banking crisis may or may not be over, but we are not out of the woods yet.

Monday, May 18, 2009

Join Together With The Band

There is an old saying which says that if you can't beat them, join them. That is exactly what is happening in some areas of the capital markets. One area is the equity market where share prices have been pushed higher by mutual funds being forced to take money of the sidelines as investor dollars continue to flow into funds. The same can be said of the high yield fixed income market. Flows into high yield funds have risen during the past month. Have investors jumped in too soon?

Maybe, maybe not. Although equity prices are rallying on not much more than hope (hope that the economy has bottomed and the economy is going to rapidly recover, its dramatic selloff during the past year was exacerbated by fear (fear that the banks were collapsing and another depression was upon us). Both the optimism now and the pessimism exhibited in 2008 and early 2009 are examples of investor overreaction. Human emotions are why markets and investing can never be reduced to mathematical formulas. There is also no "reversion to the mean" (sorry equity strategists). Truthfully there is now "mean". The markets and economy are ever-changing. Each new reality is different from the one which preceded it.

Equities are not my forte'. Fixed income is my bailiwick. Take heed of my warning that many high yield bonds have rallied too far too fast. Which ones have gone too far? I wish I knew. There lies the rub. With corporate defaults still historically low, but expected to rise, there are probably more land mines ahead. As a bond guy many of my readers may not expect me to advocate bond funds (I really don't like funds or managers for fixed income investing), but since investing in high yield bonds is a speculative endeavor and is very equity-like strategically speaking, using a bond fund for high yield bond investors may be the way to go. After all, high yield bonds should be used as speculative total return instruments and not as income-generating vehicles.

The FASB passed regulations which will force banks to move off-balance-sheet assets (many of which are toxic or potentially so) onto bank balance sheets. This could put banks under renewed pressure. More on that tomorrow.

Thursday, May 14, 2009

Good Morning, Good Morning, Good Morning!

Today, fixed income investors received a few wake up calls. Whether they were listening is another matter.

The calls and e-mails keep pouring in asking if investors should participate in the GM exchange offer to swap their senior debt for common equity. I have my own opinions about going lower on the capital structure (don't do it), but it is a moot point with the GM exchange. It is not going to happen. To avoid bankruptcy, GM would need 90% investor participation in the exchange. No 90% and no one gets exchanged. Why won't most GM bondholders exchange their debt for equity? Because in a bankruptcy (if the rule of law still means anything in this country), GM creditors are entitled to much more than a 10% ownership stake.

I am not the only one who believes that a GM bankruptcy is likely. GM CEO Fritz Henderson also believes that a GM bankruptcy is inevitable. Since, unlike with Chrysler, most GM bondholders are not TARP banks, President Obama may not be able to pressure creditors into committing economic suicide.

Last week there was much euphoria on Wall Street because initial jobless claims fell. Well they're up again. Sorry boys and girls, real estate values continue to decline. Companies continue to pare workers. Retail sales are not stellar and could get worse as the beneficial effects of tax refunds wain. Better earnings among retailers have been mostly due to cost cutting. That an only go so far.

What about inflation? Optimists are quick to point out that deflation is only really occurring in food, energy and real estate. Today's PPI report bears that out. However, those were the only sectors experience consistent inflation during the last economic expansion.

I am not an equity strategist, but with few tools left to stimulate growth and consumer spending to levels seen during the two decades of falling rates beginning 1982 (can't make borrowing rates and standards lower), I think returns in the stock market over the next 1o years will have difficulty outperforming the current 10-year yield of 3.10%. That's no bull.

Wednesday, May 13, 2009

We're Not Gonna Take It

The following is my letter to Chrysler LLC:

am disappointed in the current situation in which Chrysler finds itself. I am even more disappointed in the way Chrysler creditors were treated. I am most disappointed in the elevation of the UAWs status in bankruptcy. I currently own five Chrysler vehicles. My most recent purchases are a 2007 Dakota Quad Cab and a 2007 Caliber R/T for my wife.

I will no longer purchase vehicles from Chrysler. I will not support a company which has a group of workers who helped run the company into the ground as its majority shareholder. It is a shame that Chrysler, the former U.S. small car leader, has to receive help from FIAT (a former U.S. market failure) for assistance.

Going forward I will only purchase vehicles made in the U.S. by foreign manufacturers in non-UAW plants

Tuesday, May 12, 2009

Dixie

I continue to get questions as to whether or not to exchange one's GM bonds for GM common as per the offer by GM. Besides that fact that GM probably does not get the required 90% bondholder participation to get the deal off the ground, why would anyone want to own common stock of an unrestructured GM being run by and for the benefit of the UAW and the government? Sure, one may receive approximately 30 or 40 cents on the dollar (depending on the price of GM equity), but receiving GM shares instead of cash is akin to being paid with Confederate dollars.

Think I am exaggerating? GM shares fell to a 76-year low of $1.12 after six GM executives unloaded their shares. This is telling. If GM executive believe the company's shares are essentially worthless, why should anyone own GM shares?

Mother's Little Helper

Many bulls believe that the economy will rebound sharply, mirroring its decline. Why do many strategists and prognosticators, believe this? Because it has happened before. Following every recession since the Paul Volcker area, the economy has experienced a healthy rebound. Economic recoveries were only a rate cuts (or cuts) away. Things are different today.

Today, Fed policy is extremely accommodative, even for a recession. Cutting short term borrowing rates to essentially zero has had some benefit, but we can't borrow our way out of this one. Since 1982, the economy had experienced a downward trend in borrowing costs. This enabled homeowners to refinance their homes time and time again. This put money back in the pockets of consumers. It also lowered monthly expenses allowing consumers to borrow to purchase big ticket items such as large trucks and SUVs. Lower borrowing rates also enabled consumers to afford larger, more expensive homes. Lower rates also opened up home ownership to more potential buyers. The real estate boom was on.

Accommodative Fed policy has been responsible for approximately 25 years of economic growth. However, this was only possible because of the poor policy decisions of the 1960s and 1970s. Equity strategists often talk about reversion to the mean. They are famous (or infamous) for describing the so-called mean. Could the economy finally reverting to the "mean"? Truth be told, there is no mean. The U.S. economy is dynamic. There is no mean, but we are entering a new era where the economy will be based more productivity and less on leverage.

If the economy will be based on productivity instead of cheap financing (after all, cheap financing has not been able to lift the economy out of the depths of the current recession), what will that mean for stock and home prices? Both asset classes will experience gradual long-term gains, but not the booming markets to which we have become accustomed. This is your grandfather's economy, without the industrial base.

This is not a bad thing, as long as the politicians can leave things alone. Politically-motivated policies to preserve jobs which have been outdated or to preserve industries which can be conducted in areas of the world which have a comparative advantage over the U.S. could result in inflation and higher rates accompanied by slow growth (see the 1970s and the Arthur Burns Fed). However, as long as the Fed is permitted to function independently of the administration, the economy should be alright. Just don't expect consistent double digit equity returns. Also, don't expect fund mangers to out perform the market by much. Many fund managers used the magic of leverage to produce above average returns. Look for leverage to be less in vogue. As the population ages, look for more emphasis to be placed on income vehicles such as bonds.


What does this mean for financial advisers? You MUST understand the capital markets. What does this mean for investors? You MUST understand the capital markets. Both advisers and investors must resist the urge to incur excessive risk in the quest for yield. Bulls make money, bears make money, but hogs get slaughtered

Monday, May 11, 2009

The Long and Winding Road

The equity markets trended lower as market participants took some profits off the table. Prices of long-dated treasuries rose today after the Fed purchased $3.51 billion of treasury bonds with maturities ranging 2026 to 2038 in an attempt to keep mortgage rates low. The Fed's attempt to reinvigorate the economy through interest rates is today's topic of discussion.

Many strategists are calling so a so-called "V-shaped recovery". Such a cycle is marked by a rapid economic decline (as we have just experienced) followed by a rapid recovery. However, no such recovery is possible as long as economic stability, never mind growth, is due to Fed policy. Many pundits point to the three-month LIBOR rate being below 1.00%. LIBOR rates have fallen due to the Fed's short-term borrowing programs and plan to buy commercial paper. Because banks can fund their short-term needs through the Fed, interbank lending has increased. The Fed is responsible for bank confidence. Mortgage rates have fallen, but not because banks are more comfortable lending for any fundamental reasons. The Fed's large purchases of treasuries, agencies and agency MBS has pushed rated lower. The Fed's extraordinary stimuli is barely keeping us flat.

Some pundits point to the fact that, other than food, energy and home prices, there isn't much deflation. That is because that, outside of food, energy and home prices, there wasn't much inflation in the years immediately preceding the recession. Prices will may not fall if they had not risen sharply during the economic boom years. If artificially low rates can only help us find a bottom, whet gets the economy back to on trend growth?

The question should be: What will on trend growth once the Fed stimulus programs are removed (after all, they cannot go on forever)? The answer is probably a long slow climb out of the economic hole we are currently in. Stifel Nicolaus strategist Joe Battipaglia believes that an elongated and modest recovery is probably in the cards. I agree with him.

Bond prices of bank bonds have improved since the release of the stress test results last Friday. It does not seem to matter that the test was not very stringent and the Fed cut some banks considerable breaks. However, the so-called Bank Vigilantes (my name for market participants who would push bank bond and stock prices lower as long as damage from toxic assets to bank balance sheets remained undisclosed) have been appeased by the stress tests. They have been appeased to the point that banks such as BAC, MS, BBT, Wachovia and just about every large bank other than Citi has been able to raise equity capital via IPOs to satisfy stress test requirements and banks have been able to issue non-FDIC guaranteed bonds to repay TARP. Banks want to separate from the government as soon as possible. Investors have been eager to invest in banks which seem poised to cut the cord. So much for the idea of investing along side of the government. Banks and their investors want to be as far from the government as is possible.


The bulls have used some ridiculous examples to prove that the economy is returning to "normal". Not only have they pointed to the lack of deflation within core economic sectors (where inflation has been tame for almost a decade), but they are pointing to percentage gains of stock prices among troubled banks. I'm sorry, a bank's stock rising from $2 to $4 could be viewed as positive, bit if that follows a decline from $30.

Again, I am not saying that the U.S. is sinking into an economic abyss just that the recovery will be long and drawn out. Bonds will rule. Corporate bonds continue to offer the best bang for the buck, but credit spreads continue to narrow as investors take cash off the sidelines. Beware anti-growth policies from the administration and Congress.