A pair of letters in today's Wall Street Journal question the validity of CPI and the Fed's wisdom only focusing on core inflation. One respondent states that higher food and energy prices are not a tax on growth and are being passed through to consumers. Let's discuss.
First, companies truly do not have much pricing power. Outside of fairly inelastic sectors of the economy, what prices have risen? Do televisions cost more? How about computers? Clothing? Nope, most prices are only modestly higher. Raise your prices and 100 producers are waiting in line to take your place.
What about the disconnect between PPI and CPI. PPI was 7.4% (YoY) as per the last report, but CPI was 4.3% (YoY). Sure doesn't look like producers can pass inflation through to me. Think there is a conspiracy in the numbers? If so, you should ask the people in the black helicopters buzzing your home.
Think that higher fuel and energy prices don't act as taxes on growth? If you are a family of four making about $75,000 total and your food an fuel bill is rising through the roof, where is the money coming from to feed your family and drive to work? It is coming from discretionary spending.
Think the Fed ignores headline inflation? Not at all, bit it knows that at best, food and energy prices sap funds from discretionary spending and, at worst, the Fed has no effect on food and energy prices. Dallas Fed President Fisher said as much today.
The truth is that the Fed could raise the Fed Funds rate to 10.00% and wit would have little effect on food and energy prices. People will eat, heat their homes and fuel their vehicles to get to work at the expense of discretionary spending.
All these are truths. However, although the Fed has trouble halting inflation, it can easily cause inflation. By lowering rates, it makes U.S. denominated securities less attractive and causes the dollar to weaken. If the dollar is worth less versus foreign currencies, foreign-made goods can cost more (China has enough margin to keep prices in check, but China is not the largest U.S. trading partner). Conversely, U.S. made goods cost less overseas.
The Fed IS helping to fuel inflation. It may even be contributing to higher oil prices. Why doesn't Mr. Bernanke take a page out of Paul Volcker's book? Because the banking system is in deep trouble and Mr. Bernanke knows it. Just wait until banks and brokers report earnings this month and next.
Tuesday, March 4, 2008
Monday, March 3, 2008
I Said Over and Over and Over Again
There are times when one has to shout, stop!!!!! Today is one of those days. I compose an internal use only fixed income report for a major investment bank. The report is sent to several thousand brokers at the firm. Each day I lay out market conditions, what it all means and where it may be heading. Every now and then I will repeat a topic, usually when there are signs that my prior concerns may prove true or may be unfounded.
Today I wrote that Bank of America may not guarantee Countrywide debt should the deal close in the third quarter of this year. My partner and I were flooded with e-mail asking if BAC is legally required to guarantee CFC debt if they merge? The answer is no.
Let's break things down. The ability of a parent to guarantee the debt of a subsidiary or vice versa (or one sub to guarantee another) is called cress default protection. You know what. Most corporations to do not have it. Ford does not guarantee Ford Motor Credit debt (or vice versa). Verizon does not guarantee its subsidiaries' debt or vice versa (nor do subs guarantee each other). To assume that BAC will back stop CFC debt is a dangerous assumption. Just as dangerous as assuming that large investment firms would always violate SEC rules and back stop ARS auctions.
I have the opportunity to work as a retail financial advisor. If I have to deal with, not only a lack of knowledge, but also a stubbornness to ignore the truth if it is not what one wants to hear, then maybe I will stick to bloviating.
Today I wrote that Bank of America may not guarantee Countrywide debt should the deal close in the third quarter of this year. My partner and I were flooded with e-mail asking if BAC is legally required to guarantee CFC debt if they merge? The answer is no.
Let's break things down. The ability of a parent to guarantee the debt of a subsidiary or vice versa (or one sub to guarantee another) is called cress default protection. You know what. Most corporations to do not have it. Ford does not guarantee Ford Motor Credit debt (or vice versa). Verizon does not guarantee its subsidiaries' debt or vice versa (nor do subs guarantee each other). To assume that BAC will back stop CFC debt is a dangerous assumption. Just as dangerous as assuming that large investment firms would always violate SEC rules and back stop ARS auctions.
I have the opportunity to work as a retail financial advisor. If I have to deal with, not only a lack of knowledge, but also a stubbornness to ignore the truth if it is not what one wants to hear, then maybe I will stick to bloviating.
Wednesday, February 27, 2008
Got To Keep The Loonies On The Path
Recent news stories are enlightening me to a painful fact. Most people no nothing about finance. I am not talking about high finance engineered in boardrooms around the globe, but personal finance. Recently, we saw how investors (and some advisers) confused the word auction with maturity. Ignorance also exists on the financing side of personal finance. It turns out, many people do not understand how their financing vehicle of choice works. Many people have no idea how lending rates are set. While the detailed story is beyond the scope of a daily blog, we will attempt to she some light on the subject.
An article on the front page of today's Wall Street Journal discusses declining home prices. One person interviewed by the Journal was disappointed because he could not refinance his adjustable-rate mortgage into a fixed-rate mortgage and thought that the lower Fed Fund rates would cause fixed rate mortgage rates to drop.
What this and many other borrowers do not understand is that the Fed does not directly influence long-term interest rates. Long-term interest rates are mostly influenced by inflation data and expectations. This is evidenced by the steep U.S. treasury yield curve. Higher inflation is preventing long-term financing rates from falling further.
Another factor preventing the refinancing of adjustable-rate mortgages is that banks have more stringent lending standards. It is more difficult to qualify for a mortgage and those who can qualify are paying a higher spread over treasuries than in the past. This is not unexpected as banks are attempting to better quantify credit risk.
One has to ask the question: Didn't borrowers realize that adjustable-rate mortgages adjust? Most did, but believed (or were duped into believing) that if rates went up, they could refinance in to a low-rate fixed-rate mortgage. Few were concerned with home prices as they always go up, no? Why someone would gamble with their home is beyond me. Never risk the roof over your head. Buy a home you can afford with a fixed-rate mortgage and be happy.
Some politicians are voicing opinions about how to bail out homeowners and preventing home prices from trending even lower. Unfortunately, failure to let prices adjust to the forces of supply and demand (there is much more supply than demand) will only deepen and prolong the pain. This is making people loony.
An article on the front page of today's Wall Street Journal discusses declining home prices. One person interviewed by the Journal was disappointed because he could not refinance his adjustable-rate mortgage into a fixed-rate mortgage and thought that the lower Fed Fund rates would cause fixed rate mortgage rates to drop.
What this and many other borrowers do not understand is that the Fed does not directly influence long-term interest rates. Long-term interest rates are mostly influenced by inflation data and expectations. This is evidenced by the steep U.S. treasury yield curve. Higher inflation is preventing long-term financing rates from falling further.
Another factor preventing the refinancing of adjustable-rate mortgages is that banks have more stringent lending standards. It is more difficult to qualify for a mortgage and those who can qualify are paying a higher spread over treasuries than in the past. This is not unexpected as banks are attempting to better quantify credit risk.
One has to ask the question: Didn't borrowers realize that adjustable-rate mortgages adjust? Most did, but believed (or were duped into believing) that if rates went up, they could refinance in to a low-rate fixed-rate mortgage. Few were concerned with home prices as they always go up, no? Why someone would gamble with their home is beyond me. Never risk the roof over your head. Buy a home you can afford with a fixed-rate mortgage and be happy.
Some politicians are voicing opinions about how to bail out homeowners and preventing home prices from trending even lower. Unfortunately, failure to let prices adjust to the forces of supply and demand (there is much more supply than demand) will only deepen and prolong the pain. This is making people loony.
Tuesday, February 26, 2008
Deep Black and Blue
Today, the financial press was rife with stories about more subprime related writedowns. Now Variable Interest Entities (VIEs) threaten to add to the pain. Look for more writedowns and possible bank and broker restructuring.
In my posting entitled "Ain't That A Shame. You're The One To Blame " I pasted financial advisers for not understanding auction-rate securities. Now PIMCO's Bill Gross is jumping on the personal responsibility bandwagon. He calls ARS "Old-maid cards foisted upon investors"
Brokers I have spoken with defend their decisions to use ARS as short-term investors because, as some claim, firms have stated they would support auctions or, they were led to believe successful auctions were guaranteed.
I have the opportunity to become a broker. My concern is that I am not a good asset-gatherer as investors like the slick sales type, not the knowledgeable analytic type who will tell it like it is.
Here is a message to investors. If you are disappointed with your broker, look in the mirror to see the one to blame.
In my posting entitled "Ain't That A Shame. You're The One To Blame " I pasted financial advisers for not understanding auction-rate securities. Now PIMCO's Bill Gross is jumping on the personal responsibility bandwagon. He calls ARS "Old-maid cards foisted upon investors"
Brokers I have spoken with defend their decisions to use ARS as short-term investors because, as some claim, firms have stated they would support auctions or, they were led to believe successful auctions were guaranteed.
I have the opportunity to become a broker. My concern is that I am not a good asset-gatherer as investors like the slick sales type, not the knowledgeable analytic type who will tell it like it is.
Here is a message to investors. If you are disappointed with your broker, look in the mirror to see the one to blame.
Monday, February 25, 2008
Lies, Lies, I Can't Believe A Word You Say
An article in today's Wall Street Journal reports that, in an attempt to win voters in Ohio, is spouting future policy which would include preventing or delaying foreclosures and freezing the interest rates of adjustable-rate mortgages. This played well with Mrs. Clinton's working class audience, but is it legal to alter the terms of mortgages by presidential or even congressional fiat?
The average person must be thinking: Banks are regulated by the Fed and are influenced by the Treasury, force policy upon the banks. The problem is that, in moist cases, the banks are not the lender of record, they are merely the servicers. The lenders are investors who own mortgage-backed securities. In order to change the terms of mortgages, investors need to approve. Binds are legally-binding agreements. Wouldn't it be to investors advantage to permit changes which would avert defaults? Maybe, but it is their decisions to make.
Think that most of the investors are independently wealthy? Guess again. Many MBS investors are surprisingly middle class. In fact, many funds found in 401Ks own MBS. How would you like the government changing the terms of your investments?
The bottom line is that all the talk of changing mortgage terms for borrowers who made poor decisions is a load of election year crap. The only mortgages which may be changed are ones where fraud can be proved and then the loans in question will probably be refinanced at the expense of the original lender or mortgage broker with investors receiving their principal.
The average person must be thinking: Banks are regulated by the Fed and are influenced by the Treasury, force policy upon the banks. The problem is that, in moist cases, the banks are not the lender of record, they are merely the servicers. The lenders are investors who own mortgage-backed securities. In order to change the terms of mortgages, investors need to approve. Binds are legally-binding agreements. Wouldn't it be to investors advantage to permit changes which would avert defaults? Maybe, but it is their decisions to make.
Think that most of the investors are independently wealthy? Guess again. Many MBS investors are surprisingly middle class. In fact, many funds found in 401Ks own MBS. How would you like the government changing the terms of your investments?
The bottom line is that all the talk of changing mortgage terms for borrowers who made poor decisions is a load of election year crap. The only mortgages which may be changed are ones where fraud can be proved and then the loans in question will probably be refinanced at the expense of the original lender or mortgage broker with investors receiving their principal.
Thursday, February 21, 2008
Little GTO
The investor community is up in arms that Wall Street firms are not supporting auctions (never mind that regulators are poised to investigate firms for bid rigging and supporting auctions which would have failed if not for firm support, unbeknownst to many investors).
It appears as though ARS was marketed with a kind of guaranteed takeout or GTO. ARS marketers allegedly reassures brokers and investors that if auctions did not receive sufficient interest to be successful, the firm running conducting the auction would step in with its own capital to ensure a successful auction. Up until now, this was true in the vast majority of potentially troubled auctions. However, just because it is true, doesn't make it right.
Much of my background comes from the trading side of the business. One of the first things one is taught is, as a seller, to never offer a guaranteed takeout to a buyer. In other words, don't sell a bond to someone with the promise that you will buy it back at a predetermined price. For one thing, do to so is an NASD violation and market conditions may change to where this promise is impossible to keep. , what is taboo (and illegal) in the cash bond market was de rigeur in the ARS market.
The questions now become: What happens first? Do investors launch lawsuits against Wall Street firms or do regulators (and attorneys general) begin fining Wall Street firms. Both could be on the horizon.
Also, think the ARS markets are coming back soon? Guess again. Muni issuers are just as upset about failed auctions (double digit interest rates will do that). They will more likely tap the conventional bond market. Another "enhanced" product bites the dust.
It appears as though ARS was marketed with a kind of guaranteed takeout or GTO. ARS marketers allegedly reassures brokers and investors that if auctions did not receive sufficient interest to be successful, the firm running conducting the auction would step in with its own capital to ensure a successful auction. Up until now, this was true in the vast majority of potentially troubled auctions. However, just because it is true, doesn't make it right.
Much of my background comes from the trading side of the business. One of the first things one is taught is, as a seller, to never offer a guaranteed takeout to a buyer. In other words, don't sell a bond to someone with the promise that you will buy it back at a predetermined price. For one thing, do to so is an NASD violation and market conditions may change to where this promise is impossible to keep. , what is taboo (and illegal) in the cash bond market was de rigeur in the ARS market.
The questions now become: What happens first? Do investors launch lawsuits against Wall Street firms or do regulators (and attorneys general) begin fining Wall Street firms. Both could be on the horizon.
Also, think the ARS markets are coming back soon? Guess again. Muni issuers are just as upset about failed auctions (double digit interest rates will do that). They will more likely tap the conventional bond market. Another "enhanced" product bites the dust.
Wednesday, February 20, 2008
Ain't That A Shame. You're The One To Blame
The recent debacle in the auction-rate securities market has resulted in much finger pointing. Investors are pointing their fingers at brokers. Brokers are pointing finegrs at marketers. Marketers are pointing their fingers at traders. They all should be pointing fingers at themselves.
Why? Let's discuss. Investors ae upset because they were, (allegedly) told by brokers that auction rate securities can be liquidated on the auction date. Brokers are upset becasue marketers told them the same thing, plus, that auctions at our firm (insert name here) never fail. Marketers are upset claiming that they were only doing their jobs marketing the product and were merely stating past performance. Blame can be spread around here.
1) If you are an investor, didn't you wonder what the actual maturity of your security was? Were you told that auctions always go off? If so, you were either lied to or were given information by someone who was lied to. Your liquidity was dependent on other investors willing to buy your ARS. This is just like any other security.
2) If you are a financial advisor, shame on you (unless you were lied to). Did you ask about the final maturity, failed auctions etc.? The prospectus definitely discussed this.
3) If you are a marketer of ARS and did not disclose the possibility of auction failures with brokers, you were negligent and irresponsible. I don't care what you were told to say or what you thought you should say. Brokers and clients should have been warned that acutions can and do fail, albeit rarely. You could have mentioned penalty rates to which investors are entitled, but the possibility of failed auctions should have been discussed.
Although I wil not cut brokers too much slack (the have a responsibility to their clients)., I will come down the hardest on sales and marketing people. Too many do not know what they are selling. They read a script and push whatever they are told to push. Sorry, I was only following orders did not cut it at Nuremburg and it doesn't cut it here.
I have been told by brokers that when some brokers and managers called prior to auction failures asking if ARS were really long-term securities in disguise, many were actually yelled at for merely askimg the question.
The truth is that ARS are in fact perpetual securities which can, in most cases, be used as a money market substitute. Investors are paid higher yields for incurring the risk of failed auctions. Investors are also rewarded for failed auctions by receiving a higher "penalty rate". Some penalty rates are sufficently high that the issuer is motivated to retire this paper. Othes do not have a terribly high penalty rate. This means that these securities could be around for a while. At least until a successful auction.
If you need a money market, inevest in a money market. There is no such thing as a free lunch or free yield.
Why? Let's discuss. Investors ae upset because they were, (allegedly) told by brokers that auction rate securities can be liquidated on the auction date. Brokers are upset becasue marketers told them the same thing, plus, that auctions at our firm (insert name here) never fail. Marketers are upset claiming that they were only doing their jobs marketing the product and were merely stating past performance. Blame can be spread around here.
1) If you are an investor, didn't you wonder what the actual maturity of your security was? Were you told that auctions always go off? If so, you were either lied to or were given information by someone who was lied to. Your liquidity was dependent on other investors willing to buy your ARS. This is just like any other security.
2) If you are a financial advisor, shame on you (unless you were lied to). Did you ask about the final maturity, failed auctions etc.? The prospectus definitely discussed this.
3) If you are a marketer of ARS and did not disclose the possibility of auction failures with brokers, you were negligent and irresponsible. I don't care what you were told to say or what you thought you should say. Brokers and clients should have been warned that acutions can and do fail, albeit rarely. You could have mentioned penalty rates to which investors are entitled, but the possibility of failed auctions should have been discussed.
Although I wil not cut brokers too much slack (the have a responsibility to their clients)., I will come down the hardest on sales and marketing people. Too many do not know what they are selling. They read a script and push whatever they are told to push. Sorry, I was only following orders did not cut it at Nuremburg and it doesn't cut it here.
I have been told by brokers that when some brokers and managers called prior to auction failures asking if ARS were really long-term securities in disguise, many were actually yelled at for merely askimg the question.
The truth is that ARS are in fact perpetual securities which can, in most cases, be used as a money market substitute. Investors are paid higher yields for incurring the risk of failed auctions. Investors are also rewarded for failed auctions by receiving a higher "penalty rate". Some penalty rates are sufficently high that the issuer is motivated to retire this paper. Othes do not have a terribly high penalty rate. This means that these securities could be around for a while. At least until a successful auction.
If you need a money market, inevest in a money market. There is no such thing as a free lunch or free yield.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)